The short answer: it depends on your job value and how people find you
Whether SEO is worth it comes down to two things: how much profit one extra job is worth to you, and whether your customers search before they buy. A roofer whose jobs run into the thousands needs very few extra jobs to cover a monthly fee. A business selling $40 services needs a lot more. A business that gets all its work from one builder or a long-standing contract may not need search at all.
Showing up in Google's free results costs nothing. Google says it never accepts money to include or rank sites in its search results, and it costs nothing to appear in its organic results. What you pay for is someone's time to improve your website, your Google Business Profile and the other places customers find you. So the real question is whether that time, yours or an agency's, wins enough work to pay for itself. The rest of this guide gives you a sum to check it, and our SEO cost guide for Australia covers what fair pricing looks like.
The break-even sum: how many extra jobs SEO has to win each month
SEO pays for itself once the profit from the extra jobs it brings in each month is bigger than the monthly fee. Agency promises can't tell you that number, but your own books can. Work it out in four steps:
- Write down the monthly fee you pay or are being quoted.
- Work out the profit on an average job: the job price minus materials, labour and other direct costs.
- Divide the fee by the profit per job. Round up to a whole job. That's how many extra jobs a month SEO has to win to break even.
- Divide that by your close rate (the share of enquiries you turn into jobs) to get the extra enquiries you need. If you win 1 in 2, double it.
| Average job | Profit per job | Extra jobs a month to break even | Extra enquiries a month at 1 in 2 |
|---|---|---|---|
| $150 job at 50% profit | $75 | 14 | 28 |
| $800 job at 40% profit | $320 | 4 | 8 |
| $5,000 job at 25% profit | $1,250 | 1 | 2 |
Put your own figures in. If the answer is one or two extra jobs, the bar is low. If it's 25 a month, SEO has to work very hard, and a cheaper fix may come first. Repeat customers and referrals add to the value of each new job, so count them if your work brings people back.
When SEO is usually worth it for a local business
SEO is usually worth it when customers search for your service in your area and the break-even number above is small. Run through this checklist. The more lines that fit, the stronger the case:
- Your break-even is a handful of jobs a month or fewer.
- People search for what you do, often with a suburb or 'near me' attached.
- Competitors show up in the Maps results for your suburbs and you don't.
- You can take on more work without hiring first.
- You plan to stay in the same area for years, so improvements keep paying.
- Customers have told you they found you, or a competitor, on Google or by asking ChatGPT.
Local search suits businesses that serve a set patch. Google says local results are mainly based on relevance, distance and popularity, so a business that serves only a few Queensland suburbs is mostly competing with businesses near those searchers, not with the whole state. A plumber in north Brisbane is mostly compared with other plumbers near the people searching there, on relevance and popularity as well as distance. Our guide to what local SEO covers explains the parts.
When SEO isn't worth it yet: fix these first
SEO isn't worth paying for yet when your break-even number is out of reach, or when something else would stop the extra enquiries turning into jobs. Paying for more visibility doesn't help if the phone goes to voicemail or the calendar is already full. Hold off, or spend on these first:
- You're booked out for months and can't take more work.
- Calls and enquiry forms go unanswered for days.
- Your job value is so low that the break-even sum needs dozens of extra jobs a month.
- You need jobs this week. Google says some SEO changes take effect in a few hours and others take several months, so paid ads may suit an urgent gap better. Our SEO versus Google Ads guide compares the two.
- Nearly all your work comes from one or two builders, agents or contracts, not the public.
Some of these change with time. A new business that fixes its answering and pricing first can come back to SEO later with a clear break-even figure, and Google says a small local business can probably do much of the work itself.
Paying an agency versus doing the basics yourself
Doing the basics yourself is worth trying first if you have a few hours a month, and paying an agency is worth it when your time costs more than the fee or the work is beyond you. Google itself says that if you run a small local business, you can probably do much of the work yourself, and it recommends starting with its SEO Starter Guide. Creating a Google Business Profile is free.
| Factor | Doing it yourself | Paying an agency |
|---|---|---|
| Cash cost | Your time; the Business Profile is free | A monthly fee |
| Your time | Hours each month, learning as you go | Less, but you still answer questions and check the work |
| Good fit for | One location, simple site, owner with spare evenings | Several suburbs or regions, busy owner, technical site work |
| Main risk | Jobs left half done | Paying for reports that don't track calls or jobs |
| Who answers for it | You | Still you: Google says you're responsible for the actions of any company you hire |
Google also names the useful services an SEO can provide, including expertise in specific markets and geographies and optimising for generative AI. If you hire, ask the questions Google suggests, including what results they expect, in what timeframe, and how they measure success.
Does AI change the answer? The same basics still count
AI search doesn't make the basics a waste of money: Google says the same SEO best practices apply to its AI features, and ChatGPT search draws on websites it is allowed to crawl. Google adds that there are no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode, nor other special optimisations necessary. On the ChatGPT side, OpenAI's help says ChatGPT can search the web for current information with links to sources and can use location information to find local results.
One technical check matters here. OpenAI says sites that are opted out of its search crawler, OAI-SearchBot, will not be shown in ChatGPT search answers, so make sure your website's robots.txt file doesn't block it. If you want to see where you stand, our guide on how to check if AI recommends your business walks through it, and is SEO dead because of AI? answers that question in full. For a small business, AI answers add another place a good profile and website get seen, which strengthens the case for the basics.
How to tell if the SEO you already pay for is working
The SEO you pay for is working if the numbers tied to calls and jobs are rising over several months, not only rankings in a report. Google suggests waiting a few weeks to judge whether a change helped, so look at trends, not single days. Check these yourself each month:
- Business Profile performance: calls from the call button, website clicks and direction requests. It only shows for verified profiles, and Google says it mixes organic results and Google Ads, so separate the two if you run ads.
- Search Console performance report: clicks from Google Search and which queries bring people to your site.
- Your own records: ask every new caller how they found you and count the jobs won.
- The agency's work log: Google suggests asking whether they will share all the changes they make to your site.
- Access: for an audit, Google advises giving read access to Search Console only, not write access.
Then rerun the break-even sum with real figures. If calls and jobs aren't climbing after several months and nobody can explain why, it's fair to ask hard questions or move on. Be wary of anyone promising a top spot: Google says no one can guarantee a number one ranking, and there's no way to request or pay for a better local ranking. If a standard form contract (one you can't negotiate) only lets the agency end it, check the ACCC's guidance on unfair contract terms, which lists one-sided termination terms as examples of terms that may be unfair.
If you'd like a second opinion on your own numbers, our AI Visibility service covers Google, Maps and AI answers for businesses across our Queensland service areas, Brisbane included, with plans from $399 a month plus GST. Call us on 0466 503 449.