Before the first call: check they are a real Australian business
The first check on any SEO agency takes a minute and costs nothing: look up its ABN. ABN Lookup gives free access to public Australian Business Number information from the Australian Business Register, with no login needed. It shows whether an ABN is active or cancelled, the business type, GST status and, where available, past trading names.
- Does the legal name on the ABN match the name on the quote and the contract?
- Is the ABN active, or cancelled?
- If the price says plus GST, does the record show the business is registered for GST?
- Do the past trading names suggest a business that keeps changing its name?
Then ask for references you can ring. Google's guide to hiring an SEO tells you to ask past clients whether the SEO gave useful service, was easy to work with and got positive results. The same page says to be wary of agencies that email you out of the blue. As an example of what you should be able to check, WaynAI's registered company is WAYNAI PTY LTD, ABN 56 695 726 071, and that number comes up on ABN Lookup like any other.
Questions about results and reporting: ask how they'll count calls
The most useful reporting question is simple: how will you show me the calls and enquiries your work brings in? A ranking chart can climb while the phone stays quiet. Google's own list of questions for an SEO includes "What kind of results do you expect to see, and in what timeframe? How do you measure your success?" Ask both parts and write the answers down.
| Ask | A good answer | An answer that should worry you |
|---|---|---|
| What will my monthly report show? | Calls and enquiries from search and Maps, by month, next to rankings | A ranking chart and a traffic graph, nothing about enquiries |
| What results do you expect, and by when? | A range tied to your suburbs, your services and where your site starts | A set position by a set date |
| Will you show me every change you make to my site? | Yes, with the reason for each one | Our process is confidential |
| Can I see the raw data? | Yes, Search Console and analytics sit in your own Google Account | Only through our dashboard |
Realistic timeframes vary by suburb and competition. Our guide on how long local SEO takes sets out what moves first.
Questions about the work itself and who does it
Ask what actually gets done in a normal month and who does it, because a monthly fee should buy work you can see. Google suggests asking an SEO whether it follows Google Search Essentials, what experience it has in your industry and your city, and whether it cites official Google documentation to back its recommendations. Google also says it doesn't evaluate or endorse third-party SEO tools, and those tools don't have access to Google's internal ranking data, so a tool's score isn't Google's opinion of your site.
- Who works on my account day to day, and can I talk to them?
- What gets done in a normal month: pages, profile updates, review requests, fixes?
- What do you need from me each month, such as photos, job details or approvals?
- Where will new links to my site come from?
Listen hard to the answer on links. Google's spam policies class buying or selling links for ranking purposes as link spam, along with using automated programs or services to create links to your site. Google says sites that break those policies may rank lower or not appear at all, and it's your site that carries that risk.
Questions about contracts, lock-in and cancelling
Before you sign, get the minimum term, the notice period and any exit fee in writing, in the contract itself. Those numbers decide what a bad year costs you.
- How long is the minimum term, and does it renew automatically?
- How much written notice do I give to cancel, and is there a fee?
- Can you change the price or what's included during the term, and can I leave if you do?
- Is this the same contract every client signs?
That last question matters because the ACCC says the law protects small businesses from unfair terms in standard form contracts. For new or varied contracts since 9 November 2023, the ACCC says this covers businesses with fewer than 100 employees or less than $10 million in annual turnover. Its examples of terms that may be unfair include terms that let one party but not the other end the contract, penalise only one party for breaching or ending it, or let only one party change the terms. Only a court can decide whether a term is actually unfair.
Questions about who owns your profile, website and data: you should
Your business should own every account an agency works in, and the agency should be a user you can remove. On Google Business Profile, Google's help page on owners and managers says an owner has full control: adding or removing users, managing the profile's details and even deleting it. Managers get mostly the same access but can't add or remove users or remove the profile. Each user needs their own Google Account, so you never hand over your password. The safe set-up is you as primary owner and the agency as a manager.
| Asset | Who should own it | Ask the agency |
|---|---|---|
| Google Business Profile | You, as primary owner | Will you join as a manager on your own Google Account? |
| Domain name | Your business | Whose name will the domain be registered in? |
| Website pages, photos and copy | You, stated in the contract | Do I keep the site and its content if I leave? |
| Search Console and analytics | You, with the agency added as a user | Will these sit in my Google Account? |
| Call tracking numbers | Agreed in writing before they go live | What happens to the numbers on my listings if I leave? |
For an audit, Google advises giving an SEO read access to Search Console only, not write access. Our Google Business Profile guide covers setting up users properly.
Questions about Google Maps and AI answers
Ask whether the agency works on Google Maps and AI answers as well as the usual search results, and how it checks what customers actually see. Google's hiring guide suggests asking whether an SEO's advice on AI experiences, sold as AEO or GEO, lines up with Google's official guidance. That guidance, on AI features and your website, says there are no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode, and that you don't need new AI text files or special markup. An agency selling a special AI file as the fix is a worry.
- Which AI tools do you check, and for which customer questions and suburbs?
- Can you show me what ChatGPT and Google say about my business now, and again in three months?
- Will you check that ChatGPT's search crawler can reach my site?
That last one is a quick, real check: OpenAI says sites opted out of its OAI-SearchBot crawler won't be shown in ChatGPT search answers. You can see where you stand first with our guide to checking if AI recommends your business. WaynAI's AI Visibility work helps local businesses get found in ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and Google Maps, suburb by suburb, from Brisbane to the regions on our Smart Hub.
Answers that should worry you: signs of a bad SEO agency
The clearest warning sign is a promised result. Google says no one can guarantee a number one ranking, and warns about SEOs that claim a special relationship with Google or a priority submit. If an agency promises first place, Google's advice is to find someone else. A promise that ChatGPT will recommend you deserves the same doubt. Under Australian consumer law, the ACCC says a business must be able to prove any claim it advertises, and that any claim it makes, including in a quotation, must be accurate and based on reasonable grounds.
- Promised rankings, or a promised AI recommendation
- A vague answer when you ask what they'll actually do (Google warns about companies that are secretive or won't explain their plans)
- A request to link to them from your site: Google says you should never have to link to an SEO
- Reports full of rankings and traffic with nothing about calls
- Your Business Profile, domain or analytics set up in their name
- A long term that only they can end
Google also points out that you're responsible for the actions of any company you hire, and deceptive content created on your behalf could get your site removed from Google's index.
A printable checklist of questions to ask an SEO agency
Ask every agency the same questions and get the answers in writing before you sign.
- What's your ABN and legal name, and can I ring two current clients?
- How will you show me calls and enquiries from your work, each month?
- What results do you expect, by when, and what does that depend on?
- Will you list every change you make to my site, with the reason?
- Who does the work, and what do you need from me?
- Where will new links come from?
- What's the minimum term, the notice period and any exit fee?
- Will I stay primary owner of my Business Profile, domain and analytics?
- What happens to tracking numbers and content if I leave?
- Do you cover Google Maps and AI answers, and how do you check them?
If you're still deciding whether to hire anyone, Google says a small local business can probably do much of the work itself, and our guide on whether SEO is worth it for a small business helps you weigh that up. For prices, see how much SEO costs in Australia.
You're welcome to run this list past WaynAI too. Our AI Visibility plans start from $399 a month plus GST, and you can read more about us before you ask.